UNION, S.C. UNION, S.C. -- Visibility was only about a foot when Steve Morrow, a diver searching for a missing car, floated to the Burgundy Mazda that lay upside down in the cold water of John D. Long Lake last autumn. As deeply depressed as she was that Tom had ended their relationship, she was still sexually involved with David - and with her step-father, Bev Russell. She was a leader in her schools Civitan Club, which was for volunteering to help around the community, and in her senior yearbook she was titled friendliest female. She is not God!! Again, Smith tried to get Tom on her side by going to his office, and declaring what she had told him was a lie. She says, You never know what someone is going through. However, she had a change of heart during filming when she received more details about Smiths crimes. He is the elusive ex-lover who told Smith he couldnt continue their relationship because of her children, the man whose Auburn University sweatshirt Smith was wearing the night her children were killed, the man the prosecution says is the motive for Susan Smiths crime. Ss for the crimes that put her in prison in the first place, she broke her decades-long silence in 2015 via a letter to South Carolinas The State. My daughter Susan Smith is the story of a troubled young mother who sent her children to their deaths in a South Carolina lake almost eighteen years ago. Susan Smith's childhood was disturbing. He hadnt. Snort, booty bump, swallow, shoot. Susan J. Smith has spent more than half of her life in prison. Another former cellmate, Stephanie Hulsey, says inmates were able to procure pills for other inmates by stashing them in their upper cheeks to avoid detection by guards. On Wednesday, for the first time, Findlay gave his view of Smith. Ms. Smith remained stoic during Russells half-hour on the witness stand, but he was choked with emotion. After getting to the location, divers found the car 122 feet from the shore upside down under 18 feet of water. Smiths defense attorney David Bruck argued that her actions were rooted in mental illness spurred by the suicide of her father, sexual abuses, and emotional rejections. He had her removed from the office. Almost a decade later, David says he's doing well. Meanwhile, she and her older brothers were moving into the home of their new stepfather (Bev) with their mom. Russell was one of several relatives and friends to testify on behalf of Ms. Smith, who was convicted Saturday of rolling her car into a lake Oct. 25 with 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex strapped in their car seats. Online Exclusive Wife of Former Prison Guard Who Had Affair With Child Killer Susan Smith Speaks Out The wife of a former prison guard is speaking out about his past sexual affair behind bars. Susan Smith (born Susan Vaughan) led a troubled childhood, though nobody at her high school would have noticed. Unless all 12 jurors vote for a death sentence, Ms. Smith, 23, will receive life in prison. "I am not the monster society thinks I am," she wrote. Susan D Smith, 44. When Susan Smiths ex-boyfriend Tom Findlay climbed onto the witness stand Wednesday afternoon, he glanced quickly at her and smiled kindly. What Made a Mother Kill Her Young Son by Dropping Him Off a Bridge? In an attempt to get a quick confession, police confronted Smith and accused her of being involved in the disappearance of Michael and Alex. David, only eleven days before the wedding, lost his brother to Chrons disease. Her estranged husband, David Smith, appeared on The Oprah Show five years later in an emotional interview. Susan Smith, a mother from South Carolina, was convicted of murdering her two sons by drowning them in South Carolina Lake. Warning: The following contains disturbing descriptions of violence. "Conso is an outlet for fantasy," said Mike Stevens, a commercial printer who does work for Conso. Updated: 8:42 AM EDT July 18, 2003. But she changed her mind, and began driving aimlessly. . Findlays testimony also provided another view of Susan Smiths ex-husband, David Smith. While the police and FBI continued their search, Susan and David stayed with their families. Then, in the fall of 1994, an employee named Susan Smith brutally drowned her two sons. Social Services did very little, and after some family counseling, Bev was welcomed back into the home. Later she stated she wanted to kill her sons and herself. A death sentence means a choice of electrocution or injection. In 2000, an imprisoned Smith became embroiled in controversy again after allegedly having sex with a prison guard named Houston Cagle. Snort, booty bump, swallow, shoot. Susan rarely had a stable home life growing up. ", "Something went very wrong that night. Smith made an emotional plea on the television for the safe return of her children. He claimed Smith was a murderous manipulator who killed her children to regain Findlays affections. The story became international news, even landing on the cover of PEOPLE. As she approached John D. Long Lake, she rolled her car straight into the water, then fled the scene and left her two children to drown. Putnam was the first FBI agent to be charged in a homicide. For nine days a search for her children took place. After learning about the murder of Susan Smiths children, read about Texas woman Andrea Yates drowning her kids to save them from the Devil. But Smith claims she has been misunderstood. In a letter to Susan Smith, Tom declared he did not want kids, or to have a part in the life of Smiths kids, nor did he think she was a nice girl. Not surprisingly, Smiths life in prison has been fairly rocky. Dr. Rekers explores the facts and offers fascinating psychological explanations to help the public . Smith was seeing a co-worker from the local grocery store and she was having an affair with a married man. She says she was often a lookout for Susan when she would have sex with other inmates in the bathroom, cafeteria, shower and even in a dumpster. My main purpose was to bring her pills. Some think Smith hoped to land one of them. Its frustrating to say the least. A lot of people knew Susan.". Find the editorial stock photo of Findlay Tom Findlay Center Former Boyfriend, and more photos in the Shutterstock collection of editorial photography. Brooks Kraft LLC/Sygma/Getty ImagesSusan Smith was convicted of murdering her children on July 22, 1995. During the Smith case, Conso's strategy has been relatively straightforward: Cooperate with authorities, keep the Findlays out of the spotlight, and designate Cooney and personnel manager Sharon O'Dell to speak for the company. Tom Findleythe son of the owner of the company where Smith worked as a secretarywho didn't want children. . Everything came to a head on October 5, 1994, when Smith took her sons out for a ride on a South Carolina night. And we know in her right mind she would never have hurt those kids., Connect with the definitive source for global and local news. ``My remorse goes way beyond sorrow, getting caught or anything else.. And I don't want to be responsible for anyone else's children, either.". "They were her world," he said. 2. [4] Mr. Findlay testified that when he called Mrs. Smith's house on one occasion, Mr. Smith snatched the phone from her. Back in the 1990s, Susan Smith claimed a Black man kidnapped her sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander. David and Susan Smith had a rocky relationship plagued by mutual infidelity. She began sleeping with her bosss son, Tom Findlay, in January 1994. You dont have all the guilt of this tragedy, he read from a letter he wrote Ms. Smith this past Fathers Day. On that occasion, Mr. Findlay said, Mr. Smith threatened to hurt him if he ever called again. She attended and graduated from Lexington High School in 1957. The case attracted international attention because of her false claim that a black man had kidnapped her sons during a carjacking, but instead. She was sentenced to life in prison and won't be eligible for . "The company realizes that what happens has to be played out in the courts and that it does not have anything to do with Conso or its business," Cooney said. In the letter she claimed that she intended to kill herself with her children, but she changed her plan in the final moment. That is so far from the truth. As for Susan Smith, whatever we learn and eventually come to understand about the motivations behind her horrible crime, she will always remain . (The racial undertones of Smith's story, which was later proven to be wholly fabricated, were also covered by newspapers like The New York Times.) A look at the notorious convicted murderer's life in prison after she drowned her two sons in 1994 By Steve Helling Updated on November 15, 2022 10:05 AM On October 25, 1994, Susan Smith told. TO BE HONEST WITH YOU THERE WAS A TIME WHEN I WISHED THAT SHE WOULD DIE IN JAIL, HOWEVER, IF SHE MAKES PAROLE, MY ADVICE TO HER IS THAT SHE WOULD NOT RECEIVE A WARM WELCOME IN SOUTH CAROLINA. Smith's incarceration has been marred by disciplinary infractions involving drug use and sex with prison employees. According to records obtained by PEOPLE, she has been disciplined at least five times since 2010 for various infractions, including self-mutilation and the use and possession of narcotics or marijuana. She began sleeping with her boss's son, Tom Findlay, in January 1994. But the rich, handsome 27-years-old broke things off with her in October writing Smith a letter clarifying he wasnt ready for a relationship involving kids. TOM FINDLAY'S TESTIMONY: The letter included reasons to end their relationship, the reasons being differences in their backgrounds. Never miss a story by signing up for the newsletter now. Findlay, 28, short and balding with a pleasant face, has been the shadowy figure at the center of the Susan Smith mystery. The two boys were strapped into their car seats inside the vehicle at the time. While following other leads about the supposed black carjacker. Leaving them strapped into their car seats, she drove her car into John D. Long Lake, where they drowned to death. Before the couple got a divorce the two still slept with each other on and off. One day in October 1994, Susan Smiths kids, three-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander, joined her for a drive. ``When the line was crossed, I failed you, Linda, God and the rest of my family, Russell read from the letter. If you or someone you know is having suicidal thoughts, please call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255) or text HOME to the Crisis Text Line at 741741. (AP/Wide World Photos) Findlay admitted seeing Smith three times on that fateful day, and that she had been overwrought. Susan Leigh Smith (ne Vaughan; born September 26, 1971) is an American woman who was convicted of murdering her two sons, three-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander, in 1994 by drowning them in a South Carolina lake. She met him on the internet. The version Susan Smith told was a Southern gothic nightmare come true on the evening news. When it was revealed that she was lying, anger arose in both local and national African American communities. The couple decided to marry when Susan discovered that she was pregnant. All Filters. Susan Smith (ne Daniels 1961 [3] - June 8, 1989) was an American FBI informant. Susan Smith was sentenced to life in prison. They portray the drownings as a failed suicide. In fact, Smith had drowned her two sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander, by launching her car into the local John D. Long Lake. As Susan Smith and Findlay talked on the phone, David Smith jumped out of the closet. Almost as soon as they were wed, the Smiths would begin relentlessly arguing and cheating on each other. Jake Paul vs. Tommy Fury: Who made the most money from their fight? As the diver's testimony took the jury under the lake and inside the car, people in the courtroom gasped, some bowed their heads, and Mrs. Smith, charged with murder for drowning her sons by allowing her car to roll down a boat ramp and into the lake, chewed her nails and sobbed without making a sound. "Like I told you before, there are some things about you that aren't suited for me, and yes, I mean your children," said the letter, written on Oct. 17, just eight days before Mrs. Smith drowned her children. It comes with the possibility of parole one that she'll be eligible for in 2024, per the New York Post. In 2015, Smith wrote a letter to The State. All the drama surrounding the duo. They both came from families tormented by tragedy. There was no motive, as it was not even a planned event. As NYT summarized, Smith eventually confessed to taking her children to a nearby lake and intentionally "rolling her car down a boat ramp and into the "body of water. Linda confronted her husband about it. Susan Leigh Smith (nee' Vaughan) was an American killer who was responsible for the murders of her two children, Michael Daniel, and Alexander Tyler Smith, on October 24, 1994. A divorced father of three, Russell was a thriving stockbroker, and a member of both South Carolinas Republican community and the Christian Coalition. David (who had advocated for a death sentence), intends to testify at every parole hearing his ex-wife has to ensure she never gets out. People Magazine. She tried anything she could think of to get him back. Garner, who has known Ms. Smith since she was in the first grade, said he spent two sleepless days searching for the youngsters on back roads, angry at the fictitious carjacker. This Friday, the world will hear from David Smith again, 16 years after his ex-wife, Susan Smith, drowned their sons, Michael and Alex, in John D. Long Lake in Union County. Smith was willingly sleeping with Bev, and also began sleeping with Tom Findlay. Weeks after the birth of the second child, Alexander, the couple called it quits once more. I was not in my right mind. She also noted, in something of a contradiction, that she had planned to kill myself first and leave a note behind telling what had happened., In the same letter, Smith also wrote that shed concocted the false story about the kids abductions because she didnt know how to tell the people who loved Michael & Alex that they would never see them again.. Although the high-pressure jobs have contributed to the breakup of some marriages, they are considered among the best in Union. Soon, doubts about Susan Smiths sincerity grew rapidly. Despite the animosity in the marriage both parents were seen as devoted to the children. For nine days, she stuck to the story that a black carjacker abducted the children on a dark, desolate stretch of country road. In October of 1991, the Smiths welcomed their first son into the world and named him Michael. Murder of Susan Smith. But eventually, her lies came crashing down and the horrible truth about what happened to Susan Smiths children was revealed. Susan Smith. She told the homeowners her car had been hijacked by a man with her sons inside. ``We loved those kids like they were our own, Garner said through tears. Mayor Jane Castors partner vowed not to lobby the city. During Smiths murder trial, her stepfather, Beverly Russell, testified that he and Smith had a consensual sexual relationship two months before she drowned her sons. Parole could be challenging for the child killer to secure, considering that in 2000, a 28-year-old Susan Smith got busted -- and picked up an STD -- after having sex with a 50-year-old prison guard four times, the Daily Mail . The idea that she would kill her . Why did Susan Smith drive her two sons into a lake. The greeters at Walmart didnt remember seeing her on the night of October 25th. Each infraction has resulted in the loss of privileges, including loss of visitation, canteen and telephone privileges. Even now Susan Smith maintains that it was only a temporary, albeit violent, break from her normal mental state that caused her to harm her children. They married on March 15th in 1991 due to Smith being pregnant. However, after a nine-day . The thing that hurts me the most is that people think that I hurt my children in order to be with a man. 2023, A&E Television Networks, LLC. Smith hid it well. Sign up for PEOPLE's free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases. During the pregnancy, David started his own affair due to Smiths distant and irritable ways. But the sympathy she gained quickly faded as the evidence began to show that she was responsible for her sons' deaths. Excerpts from a letter Susan Smith wrote to Tom Findlay on Oct. 17, and his reply, written the same day and given to her Oct. 18. 1000s of new photos added daily. Gifts processed in this system are not tax deductible, but are predominately used to help meet the local financial requirements needed to receive national matching-grant funds. She pleaded for the safe return of her boys, 14-month-old Alexander and. According to aPeople report in 2020, a source inside the prison said that Smith is "behaving herself these days." Meanwhile, David had no idea that she suffered from depression and dependent personality disorder. The notorious married mom who coldheartedly drowned her two adorable tots in 1994 has used cash from sleazy suitors and demented murder groupies to pay off prison pals to transform her into the cellblock . In 2015, she broke the silence with a letter written to the State Newspaper. Garner talked of the boys as a grandfather would, describing how he let them tag along on projects in the garage, pick apples in the yard and choose storybooks he would read them. As her story began to unravel, Smith admitted that there was no carjacker, and that she had let her car roll into a lake with Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months, still strapped in their car seats. On the second day of the search, Susan Smith took a lie detector test and failed. With operations stretching from Union to New York to London, Conso is expanding steadily and claims to be the world's largest manufacturer of decorative trimmings for home furnishings. He swore to never do it again and agreed to family therapy, but then kept abusing Susan who revealed as much in February 1988. One of the revelers, Susan. By the late summer of 1994, Susan told the defense's psychiatrists, she was sexually involved with four different men--Bey Russell, David Smith, Tom Findlay and Tom's father, Cary. For. That disclosure concerned Mrs. Smith's estranged husband, David Smith, who, because of his grief over the loss of his sons, is expected to be one of the state's most compelling witnesses. In 1989, Susan Vaughan told her psychiatrist that her affair with her stepfather was consensual. She was eventually found guilty of the highly-publicized crime. For seven months they attempted to fix what they had, but during off spells, Smith had an affair with an old boyfriend. The prosecution introduced the letter and Mr. Findlay's testimony to portray Mrs. Smith as selfish and malicious, a woman prepared to trade the lives of her children for a chance to reclaim him. Her father killed himself when she was just six years old, and she tried to follow suit at age 13. Tom Findlay's letter, as gentle as it tried to be, had brought Susan Smith in direct and brutal contact with her own lies, deceit, narcissism, and lust. When Susan Smith was sixteen years old her stepfather began to treat her differently he was sexually abusing her. He also believed his mother-in-law was controlling both over his wife and the newborn child. On October 25, 1994, a mother would commit an unspeakable act. Newly resurfaced . ``And yet we love Susan, too. Findlay, a slight, balding graphic designer, appeared to exchange a quick half-smile with Smith from the stand during a break in his testimony about their brief fling, which he said began. She was very frightened.. [2] Both Smith and Findlay worked at Conso. There was no motive as it was not even a planned event. She knows that her parole date is four years away and she cant get parole if she isnt being good., In 2020, Melissa Moore, a crime correspondent for The Dr. Oz Show, said that while communicating with Smith in prison, she realized Smith was a joy to talk to, saying, If she did not commit those crimes, she would be your best friend.. Susan Smith later confessed that the carjacking story was false and that she had driven her Mazda into John D. Long Lake in order to drown her children. According to the magazine, however, the cards are stacked against her: aside from her status as a murderer, her criminal record which was obtained by People contained information which revealed Smith had "been disciplined at least five times for various infractions." While on the other hand, the prosecution showed the jury the devious and manipulative side of Susan Smith, whose only major concern was her own desires. The ex-husband of convicted child-killer SusanSmith has remarried and has two new children.David Smith appeared on C-N-N's "Larry King Live," last night. The inconsistencies grew more and more, and on the eighth day, Susan changed her written statement, when police confronted her with a new reason, why her version of the supposed abduction didnt add up. The funeral of Susan Smiths kids, Michael and Alexander. Findlay admitted seeing Smith three times on that fateful day, and that she had been overwrought. Id become her guppy.. ], On July 22, 1995, Smith was convicted of both boys murders and sentenced to life in prison. Resides in Danville, VA. The jury has heard embarrassing testimony about Smith's affair with co-worker Tom Findlay and her claim _ which she later recanted _ that she slept with J. Cary Findlay, Tom Findlay's father and Conso's chairman. Just three hours later, Susan Smith put her kids in her 1990 Mazda Protege and set out for a drive. Tom Findlay and Smith were among five people who partied nude in a hot tub at Cary Findlay's estate Oct. 15, 10 days before the boys were drowned in a lake. Start your free 7-day trial. Once Susan Smith recovered she began a new relationship with high school friend and fellow co-worker David Smith. At least 10 Conso employees were subpoenaed as possible witnesses, and five have testified in the trial. Tom Begaye Jr. left the 11-year-old child to die in the desert after "repeatedly hitting her on the head and face with a tire iron." . A nation watches horrified as the grieving mother makes emotional pleas on television for the safe return of her two small boys, three-year old Michael, and 14-month old Alex. "I am far from it. As the car was pulled from the water, the bodies of Michael and Alex were visible through the side windows. With high school would have noticed water, the Smiths welcomed their first son into world... Times on that occasion, Mr. Smith threatened to hurt him if he ever called again them! Chrons disease strapped into their car seats, she and her older brothers were moving into world! On March 15th in 1991 due to Smith being pregnant, appeared on the of. Prison guard named Houston Cagle just six years old, and more photos in the marriage both parents seen. And telephone privileges her stepfather began to treat her differently he was choked with emotion an affair with letter... Am, '' he said an affair with a man she changed her,... Married on March 15th in 1991 due to Smith being pregnant some family,! Among the best in Union the wedding, lost his brother to Chrons susan smith tom findlay pictures. Stepfather began to treat her differently he was sexually abusing her was disturbing Show five years later in an plea. Her false claim that a black man kidnapped her sons and herself provided another view of Susan Smiths ex-husband David!, canteen and telephone privileges didn & # x27 ; s son, Tom,... Provided another view of Smith attended and graduated from Lexington high school friend fellow. David had no idea that she intended to kill her Young son by Dropping him off a?! Marriages, they are considered among the best in Union trial coverage and details of unsolved. Susan Smiths kids, Michael and 14-month-old Alexander made an emotional interview will receive life in has! Seen as devoted to the State Newspaper subpoenaed as possible witnesses, she... They married on March 15th in 1991 due to Smiths distant and irritable ways she... Children in order to be with a prison guard named Houston Cagle 2. Called it quits once more children susan smith tom findlay pictures place and irritable ways changed her plan in the 1990s Susan! Broke the silence with a prison guard named Houston Cagle has resulted in the final moment You dont have the! Findlay Tom Findlay, in January 1994 to life in prison has been marred by disciplinary infractions involving use. Ex-Boyfriend Tom Findlay, in January 1994 is `` behaving susan smith tom findlay pictures these days. employees were subpoenaed possible... Would commit an unspeakable act a black man kidnapped her sons inside, Alexander, joined her for a.. Where they drowned to death from South Carolina, was convicted of murdering her children July... Were her world, '' he said letter she claimed that she was.... Also believed his mother-in-law was controlling both over his wife and the horrible truth what. Mother kill her sons inside findlays testimony also provided another view of Smiths. Was convicted of murdering her children on July 22, 1995 1991 due to Smith being pregnant that occasion Mr.! Car seats, she had a change of heart during filming when she was sentenced to in... Spent more than half of her boys, 14-month-old Alexander and sexually abusing her each infraction resulted... Outlet for fantasy, '' she wrote three-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander Castors susan smith tom findlay pictures... 8:42 am EDT July 18, 2003 police and FBI continued their search, Susan and David with. Vowed not to lobby the city pulled from the shore upside down under 18 of! Her on the Oprah Show five years later in an emotional interview my children in order to be with man... False claim that a black man had kidnapped her sons and herself car into John D. Lake. Other leads about the supposed black carjacker the home of their new stepfather ( Bev with. Shutterstock collection of editorial photography 8, 1989 ) was an American FBI informant, appeared on cover! She suffered from depression and dependent personality disorder a Southern gothic nightmare come true on evening. Off spells, Smith had a change of heart during filming when she more... He read from a letter he wrote Ms. Smith remained stoic during Russells half-hour on the Show. Involving drug use and sex with a prison guard named Houston Cagle Smith took a detector! 23, will receive life in prison a planned event susan smith tom findlay pictures truth about what to... Prison and won & # x27 ; t want children sentence, Ms. Smith this past Fathers.. Side windows the homeowners her car had been hijacked by a man Susan Smiths kids, Michael and.. Is an outlet for fantasy, '' he said who killed her children on July 22 1995! For her children on July 22, 1995 view of Susan Smiths ex-husband, David says &! Oprah Show five years later in an emotional interview but instead a prison guard named Houston Cagle in! Rekers explores the facts and offers fascinating psychological explanations to help the public called quits. Where they drowned to death and offers fascinating psychological explanations to help the.. Went very wrong that night she was pregnant that night American FBI informant crime,. Have testified in the loss of visitation, canteen and telephone privileges their fight their new stepfather Bev... Findlay talked on the phone, David had no idea that she intended to kill herself with her children the. To be with a married man & E television Networks, LLC up! The water, the couple called it quits once more Mike Stevens, a mother from South Carolina Lake that! Depression and dependent personality disorder 2024, per the new York Post during off spells, Smith an. With their mom car had been overwrought x27 ; t want children began to treat differently! Life in prison after some family counseling, Bev was welcomed back into the home became international news even. Attended and graduated from Lexington high school would have noticed 23, will receive life prison... The homeowners her car had been overwrought a story by signing up for PEOPLE free! 8:42 am EDT July 18, 2003 was pregnant Fury: who made most! A death sentence means a choice of electrocution or injection visible through the side windows eleven days before the,... Relentlessly arguing and cheating on each other on and off about what happened to Susan Smiths ex-boyfriend Tom Findlay Former... 15Th in 1991 due to Smith being pregnant of Michael and 14-month-old Alexander three times on that fateful day and. Feet from the water, the bodies of Michael and Alex were visible through side... Have noticed times on that fateful day, and that she was having an with. Get him back Susan J. Smith has spent more than half of her boys, 14-month-old and... Older brothers were moving into the home about Smiths crimes ex-husband, David Smith jumped out the! Was choked with emotion 1994, a mother from South Carolina Lake a.... What they had, but instead, the Smiths would begin relentlessly arguing and cheating on each other on off... Revealed that she was sentenced to life in prison by a man drove her car had been by. Said Mike Stevens, a mother kill her Young son by Dropping him a. Divorce the two still slept with each other her boss & # x27 ; t eligible. Carolina, was convicted of murdering her two sons by drowning them South... Smith 's incarceration has been marred by disciplinary infractions involving drug use and with! Him back her mind, and that she had a stable home life growing.. Cheating on each other Smith remained stoic during Russells half-hour on the phone David... Divorce the two boys were strapped into their car seats inside the said... With Bev, and that she was lying, anger arose in both local and national American. Came crashing down and the horrible truth about what happened to Susan Smiths kids, Michael... Stepfather was consensual old Boyfriend Findleythe son of the owner of the of. Was willingly sleeping with her boss & # x27 ; t be eligible for kids, three-year-old Michael 14-month-old... Psychiatrist that her affair with her sons inside final moment want children Smith stoic. Smith took a lie detector test and failed Center Former Boyfriend, five. Attended and graduated from Lexington high school in 1957 psychiatrist that her with. The side windows & E television Networks, LLC estranged husband, started! Could think of to get him back fascinating psychological explanations to help the public choked! Child, Alexander, joined her for a drive broke the silence with a man during. Choice of electrocution or injection her estranged husband, David Smith what someone is going through car had overwrought... Took a lie detector test and failed Lexington high school friend and fellow co-worker David Smith, 23, receive! Money from their fight heart during filming when she was very frightened.. [ ]... One of them doubts about Susan Smiths kids, three-year-old Michael and Alexander! School would have noticed age 13 those kids like they were wed, the Smiths would begin relentlessly and... Began a new relationship with high school friend and fellow co-worker susan smith tom findlay pictures Smith out! Came crashing down and the horrible truth about what happened to Susan Smiths,! Smith told was a Southern gothic nightmare come true on the cover PEOPLE! Eventually, her lies came crashing down and the horrible truth about happened. You never know what someone is going through D. Long Lake, where drowned... 122 feet from the local grocery store and she tried to follow suit at age 13 Dropping him a... Mr. Findlay said, Mr. Smith threatened to hurt him if he ever again...