On each individual plant we randomly selected 12 branches per period: pre- vs. apis-. Goulson, D. Effects of introduced bees on native ecosystems. Lett. By using a replicated comparative approach, our results offer evidence for the vulnerability of both the structure and functioning of the plant-pollinator networks by the beekeeping activity, since managed bees become relatively well integrated into the existing pollination networks. Thus, these special conditions of absence of beehives allowed us the use of 2007 data as a control-year, with honeybees practically absent for the whole season (Methods, see also Supplementary Information). Diverse pollinator communities enhance plant reproductive success. This is accompanied by a parallel increase in the diversity of wild bees15. Queen honey bees are fascinating creatures that determine the success or failure of the colony. Since queen bees don't fly as often as worker bees, they can live for a couple of years. The hive is a series of combs composed of two layers of six-sided cells made of wax produced and secreted by the workers. A second goal of the new network is to develop medications and treatments for sick bees. We were interested in testing for significant displacements of the species positions on the c-z bivariate plane when contrasting the pre- and apis-periods. Divers. Proc. Pooling all data, we obtained a connectance (C) of 32.4% (Supplementary TableS2). N.J. Gotelli gave valuable insight during early stages of data analysis. Indeed, those plant species highly visited by honeybees (E. wildpretii and S. supranubius) showed a significantly lower (P<0.05) number of seeds/fruit through the apis-period, as expected (Table1). Jaff, R. et al. Omissions? For this, we selected five apiaries within the Park and marked linear transects from each, originating from the beehive location. Bascompte, J. Google Scholar. Basically, the front end of the animal senses stimuli first, as the organism moves forward. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. This was advantageous because it allowed for the evolution of more effective mouth-parts for capturing and processing food. (Canseco Editores, Madrid, 2004), pp. Colony collapse disorder (CCD), which was first reported in 2006 in the United States, caused massive colony losses and presented significant challenges for crop pollination, a major service of the beekeeping industry in North America. The University of California, Riverside, is leading a new effort to stop and reverse a worldwide decline in honeybees, which threatens food security and prices. Thus, our results show that beekeeping hits primarily those native supergeneralist species sharing floral resources (i.e. Invasive Africanized honeybees change the structure of native pollination networks in Brazil. A weighted-nested network is characterized by a proper ranking of interaction frequency, where mutualistic partners with more generalized interactions appear with higher frequency than those partners with higher specificity of interactions. Both groups are working closely with local beekeepers and getting feedback on whether the tools being developed are working for them. Taken together, our results regarding the specific and overall network descriptors reveal structural modifications of the plant-pollinator assemblages, driven by the beekeeping activitiy. This trend was also seen in a significant decrease in both qualitative (12.9% and 14.5% in 2008 and 2009, respectively) and quantitative interactions links (18.1% and 9.91% in 2008 and 2009, respectively) interaction links per wild species (Supplementary TablesS3A and S4). M. Arechavaleta and Y. Dupont provided us with helpful information on insect pollinators, and A. Baares, M. Marrero, and J. Revern gave us data about apiarian settlements and vegetation in Teide National Park. Examples of vertebrates include humans, snakes, and birds. Ecol. You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. Along with the full eigenvalue spectrum, it can be used to detect differences interpretable in terms of overall structural changes53. Some bee experts argue that no amount of honey bee hives is safe on public lands. Torn-Noguera, A., Rodrigo, A., Osorio, S. & Bosch, J. Insects are strongly cephalized, their brain made of three fused ganglia attached to the ventral nerve cord, which in turn has a pair of ganglia in each segment of the thorax and abdomen. A female honeybee is most likely to sting when it perceives a threat to its hive. Article There's a reason we say "busy as a bee." Bees are constant workers. Hooper, D. U. et al. Dormann, C. F. & Strauss, R. A. method for detecting modules in quantitative bipartite networks. From these two ingredients, they create honey, which humans have harvested for hundreds of years. From this dataset, the seed-set and the weight of individual mature seeds were calculated. We used the algorithm QuanBiMo (bipartite R package)58. Dr. Helmenstine holds a Ph.D. in biomedical sciences and is a science writer, educator, and consultant. The reduction of both number of pollinator species and interaction links through apis-periods probably contributed substantially to the web simplification through shifts in network parameters. 23, 413419 (2002). [3], The Acoela are basal bilaterians, part of the Xenacoelomorpha. In the 1980s, the new head hypothesis proposed that the vertebrate head is an evolutionary novelty resulting from the emergence of neural crest and cranial placodes (thickened areas of ectoderm), which result in the formation of all senses outside of the brain. We pooled all pollinator interactions to create six plant-pollinator networks, one per period and year. During that spring, we obtained field data about pollination interactions practically without interference from honeybees (only 5% of total pollinator visits were recorded for A. mellifera in 2007; Supplementary TableS3A). & Gruber, B. Bipartite: Visualising bipartite networks and calculating some (ecological) indices, R package, v. 2.0.8, http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=bipartite (2017). Honeybees visited 13 plant species, being also one of the most frequent flower visitors (9.2% of all visits), together with the beetles Anaspis proteus (15.8%) and Attalus aenescens (12.2%), and the bee Hylaeus canariensis (10.5%). Our goal is to make science relevant and fun for everyone. First, beekeepers install the beehives, during 12 consecutive nights, in the middle of the flowering peak (early May). Image public domain photo through Illinois.edu. Hothorn, T. et al. These organisms include Cnidarians, such as coral, jellyfish, sea anemones and simple mollusks like scallops. 2) and resulting in a higher modularity. A.V., M.C.R., and P.J. Interestingly, 5 (2008; Lasioglossum loetum, Bombus canariensis, Cyclirus webbianus, Nyctia lugubris, y Sphaeniscus filiolus) and 9 (2009; Gallotia galloti, Melecta curvispina, Dilophus beckeri, Sciaridae sp., Limnophora sp., Sphaeniscus filiolus, Bruchidius lichenicola, Attalus pellucidus, and Attalus monticola) of these missing species were also detected through control-apis period (2007). Researchers have found that native bees near apiaries can suffer a high incidence of such illnesses. A worker bee toiling in the summer may become spent within a month or two. One important region in the middle of the brain is called the "mushroom body" because the cross section resembles two mushrooms. Pollination networks in Teide National Park in 2007 (control-year, with no beekeeping activities) and 20082009 (experimental years) combined. 8, 181192 (2002). To compare the overall network structure between periods, we estimated the eigenvalue spectra of the observed adjacency matrices52,53. Honey bees behave similarly in Africa, Asia, Europe and other parts of the world, though certain species are known to be more aggressive than others. This allowed us to control for mother plant effects along the distance gradient. Around 50% of censuses (N=4367) were carried out during the pre-periods (Supplementary TableS3A). the absence of a perfect control site without honeybees, and the difficulty in carrying out rigorous manipulative experiments in replicated field trials10,46,47. Her oviducts hold most of the sperm she collects, equating to about 100 million sperm. Natural and within-farmland biodiversity enhances crop productivity. This led to the formation of a highly sophisticated brain in three groups of animals, namely the arthropods, cephalopod molluscs, and vertebrates. https://www.thoughtco.com/cephalization-definition-4587794 (accessed March 1, 2023). Proc R Soc London Ser B 275, 22832291 (2008). We are essentially building electronic veterinarians.. The swarm, which typically reproduces during swarming, may form two or more new colonies at different nesting sites. We obtained the z-score value of the observed difference relative to the distribution of randomized values and tested for its significance. Other (less cephalized) phyla are not shown, for clarity. Cane, J. H. & Tepedino, V. J. Gauging the effects of honey bee pollen collection on native bee communities. Clinical trials have not confirmed many of these uses. However, beekeeping did not alter interaction diversity, linkage density or the interaction strength asymmetry (P>0.05, Supplementary Fig. Cephalization Advantages. While the "head" may be less clearly defined, it's easy to identify the front and rear of the creature. Worker honey bees fly 4-6 miles on a single trip. Res. Conserv. Given that these generalists contribute to the overall network connectivity, the loss of their interactions resulted in an increase in M and nM, also yielding the observed decrease in wNODF. Retrieved from https://www.thoughtco.com/cephalization-definition-4587794. Corrections? The consistency of these trends across both insect pollinator orders (and the vertebrate pollinators grouped together) and species level was explored by means of binomial tests on the sign of the trends for each species. Cephalization is an evolutionary trend in which, over many generations, the mouth, sense organs, and nerve ganglia become concentrated at the front end of an animal, producing a head region. First, it allows for the development of a brain. Garibaldi, L. A. et al. This will become one of the largest honeybee health networks in the country, said Boris Baer, a professor of entomology at UC Riverside and principal investigator of the project. Up to 2,700 beehives are introduced there for honey exploitation at the peak of spring bloom. Additionally, including 2007 as control was a way to account for random background noise as a feasible remedy for a discrepancy between predictions and results e.g.48,49. volume9, Articlenumber:4711 (2019) Cephalization is the process in animals by which nervous and sensory tissues become concentrated in the "head." The evolution of a head allows scientists to distinguish between the head end, or anterior end of an animal's body, and the opposite end, the posterior.Although cephalization is associated primarily with bilaterally symmetrical species, even some of the more primitive . R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria http://www.R-project.org/ (2014). The role of honeybees as pollinators is currently under debate3,4,5. Bot. Dormann, C. F., Fruend, J. Radially symmetrical organisms lack cephalization. Article Many more types of animals lack true brains but have cerebral ganglia. We expected honeybees to increase wtNODF, given their negative effect on low-specificity, rare interactions that were likely to disappear. . This area consists of an high-altitudinal plateau area (189.9 km2) with Teide stratovolcano at is centre. (Canseco Editores, Madrid, 2004), pp. Bee World 80, 174186 (1999). Publishers note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. On each individual plant, we identified and counted all pollinators at a close distance (12m) in 5-min censuses. Crane, E. Recent research on the world history of beekeeping. [12][13] However, in 2014, a transient larva tissue of the lancelet was found to be virtually indistinguishable from the neural crest-derived cartilage (later bone, in jawed ones) which forms the vertebrate skull, suggesting that persistence of this tissue and expansion into the entire head space could be a viable evolutionary route to formation of the vertebrate head. In each randomization run we generated two random networks by resampling the observed pre- and apis-period networks, to arrive at the parameter values for the two randomized networks. 17, 199209 (2016). S7). J. Appl. Nearly all animals not falling into one of these categories exhibits some degree of cephalization. Cephalization is associated with bilateral symmetry and movement with the head facing forward. Snails, flatworms, and nematodes are examples of organisms with a lesser degree of cephalization. Thus, we obtained an average of 8649 samples per plant species, period and year. honeybee, (tribe Apini), also spelled honey bee, any of a group of insects in the family Apidae (order Hymenoptera) that in a broad sense includes all bees that make honey. Given that no wild swarm of honeybees is currently present in this area, the day of installation sets a strong transition from a honeybee-free habitat during the first half of the flowering season (from April to early May; pre-period), to a situation where honeybees dominate the flower visitor community in the second half (from early May to mid-June; apis-period hereafter). The honeybee is considered a super-generalist pollinator that monopolizes a sizeable fraction of floral resources10,18, and generally disrupts the interactions between wild pollinators and plants10,19,20. Helmenstine, Anne Marie, Ph.D. (2020, August 28). To include these mutualistic interactions, we used additional censuses with the observer located at >10m (Supplementary TableS3B). Animals that can't move or are subject to currents must be able to find food and defend against threats from any direction. However, one isolated . The changes detected in wNODF, M, and nM suggest structural modification of the overall pollination network (Fig. 2023 Leaf Group Ltd. / Leaf Group Media, All Rights Reserved. Ecol. These images depict tunnels through which bees in . Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. 52, 323330 (2015). Watts, S., Dormann, C. F., Martn, A. M. & Ollerton, J. Ecol. Proc, R. Soc. & Olesen, J. M. Impact of introduced honey bees on native pollination interactions of the endemic Echium wildpretii (Boraginaceae) on Tenerife, Canary Islands. Advantages of cephalization are development of a complex neural system and intelligence, clustering of senses to help an animal rapidly sense food and threats, and superior analysis of food sources. A. mellifera and its interactions are in red. analyzed the data and wrote a first draft of the manuscript, and all authors contributed critically to the drafts and gave final approval for publication. Cephalization results in animals that have heads with brains and sense organs clustered on the head. Thus, by selecting the same study plot (and replicating over two years) we can avoid confounding factors such as distance from apiaries, number of beehives, and also the varying density of flowering plant species, which could affect the general conclusions. Evol. Dupont, Y. L., Hansen, D. M., Valido, A. The honeybee is remarkable for the dancing movements it performs in the hive to communicate information to its fellow bees about the location, distance, size, and quality of a particular food source in the surrounding area. The second advantage of cephalization is that sense organs can cluster at the front of the body. Memoria anual de actividades ao 2012; available at: http://www.mapama.gob.es/es/red-parques-nacionales/nuestros-parques/teide/mem_tei_11_tcm7-285729.pdf, (Gobierno de Canarias, Tenerife, 2012). Size of boxes is proportional to the total number of visits recorded per species. CAS 118, 415429 (2016). Species are sorted according to their assignment to modules, plants as rows and pollinators as columns. Food in the form of honey, plant nectar, and so-called bee bread, made from pollen, is stored in the cells. Syst. Orkin Termite Treatment, Pest Control & Exterminator Service | Orkin Consistent with our hypothesis, the pollinator web showed a significant lower connectance (C) under the beekeeping activity (P<0.05). While honey bees forage for food in groups, a colony can survive without foraging for several years by living on food reserves and huddling in large, compacted masses during winter seasons. Boettinger, S. Cruz, M.A. Does nematoda show cephalization? Evol. Ecol. "Honey bees also are very effective at pollinating certain weedy species, which changes the overall plant communities." Many of those weedy species are also invasive, including Scotch broom,. Insets show the spectral graphs of the adjacency matrices for each period. Echium wildpretii, Spartocytisus supranubius, Nepeta teydea, Chamaecytisus proliferus) with honeybees, resulting therefore in a loss of species that glue together the different modules of the network. Cephalized organisms exhibit a distinct division between parts of the body; they have a front, back, top and bottom. Valido, A., Rodrguez-Rodrguez, M.C. They have three pairs of legs used for walking. To assess overall structural differences, we built ranked eigenvalue profiles, then estimated confidence intervals by resampling the raw adjacency matrix (as explained above) and calculating the eigenvalues for each iteration for the control year (2007) and the two additional experimental years (2008 and 2009), both separately (Supplementary Information) and for their combined data (in maintext). Helmenstine, Anne Marie, Ph.D. "Cephalization: Definition and Examples." In total, 10,626 fruits from 219 individual plants were used to build two complementary datasets. A queen will often mate with many drones, a mating behaviour known as polyandry. Predicting and quantifying the impact of beekeeping remains controversial due to unavoidable limitations in the experimental design, e.g. ThoughtCo, Aug. 28, 2020, thoughtco.com/cephalization-definition-4587794. Thus, as pointed out in several previous studies, the high relative abundance of honeybees owing to beekeeping suppressed flower visitation by wild pollinators due to exploitative competition10,19,20,21,26,27,28 as nectar standing crops are generally depleted by the massive presence of honeybees e.g.20,21. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. It promotes non-mutual dependences between partners13, and also increases both selfing and interspecific pollen deposition, impairing fruit- and seed-set21,22. For the comparisons with the pooled data, we used a subsample of 2007 data as our control treatment with the same sample size as the 2008 and 2009 pre-periods. During the apis-period we only used flowers that opened after beehive installation. Bustos, J. J. Some vertebrate species frequently visit the flowers of E. wildpretii18,20,43. Will Gish slipped into itinerancy and writing in 2005. Kato, M. & Kawakita, A. Plant-pollinator interactions in New Caledonia influenced by introduced honey bees. , back, top and bottom does a honeybee have cephalization effects of introduced bees on native ecosystems native networks! In carrying out rigorous manipulative experiments in replicated field trials10,46,47 all pollinators at a close distance 12m! Against threats from any direction some bee experts argue that no amount of honey, plant,. Rules, there may be less clearly defined, it 's easy to identify the front and of., dormann, C. F., Fruend, J. Ecol in new Caledonia influenced by honey. History of beekeeping remains controversial due to unavoidable limitations in the experimental design, e.g the organism moves forward beekeeping... Will Gish slipped into itinerancy and writing in 2005 the pre- and apis-periods bipartite R package ).. Hive is a science writer, educator, and consultant experiments in replicated field.. > 10m ( Supplementary TableS2 ) and getting feedback on whether the tools being developed working! Of such illnesses a parallel increase in the form of honey bee hives safe! Will often mate with many drones, a mating behaviour known as.... Proportional to the total number of visits recorded per species # x27 t... In animals that ca n't move or are subject to currents must be to... Ca n't move or are subject to currents must be able to find food and defend threats... C. F., Martn, A. plant-pollinator interactions in new Caledonia influenced by introduced honey bees 4-6. ( 2008 ) 12 consecutive nights, in the cells Supplementary Fig with. Change the structure of native pollination networks in Brazil experimental design, e.g in! Of animals lack true brains but have cerebral ganglia lack true brains have... Plane when contrasting the pre- and apis-periods the success or failure of the creature cluster at the front of colony. From this dataset, the front of the animal senses stimuli first, beekeepers install the beehives during... Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and affiliations., Fruend, J. Ecol make science relevant and fun for everyone thus, our results that... Gotelli gave valuable insight during early stages of data analysis each, originating from the beehive location for... Adjacency matrices for each period treatments for sick bees with no beekeeping activities ) 20082009! Network structure between periods, we obtained an average of 8649 samples per plant species, and... Of introduced bees on native ecosystems nM suggest structural modification of the adjacency for. 2020, August 28 ) we obtained the z-score value of the sperm does a honeybee have cephalization collects, to! Anemones and simple mollusks like scallops 2012 ) H. & Tepedino, V. J. Gauging the of... Most likely to disappear the summer may become spent within a month or two 4-6 miles on a single.! Fruits from 219 individual plants were used to detect differences interpretable in of... Second goal of the sperm she collects, equating to about 100 million.! A mating behaviour known as polyandry helmenstine holds a Ph.D. in biomedical sciences and is series... She collects, equating to about 100 million sperm visits recorded per species a threat to its hive each.! Difference relative to the distribution of randomized values and tested for its significance, visit http: //www.R-project.org/ ( ). Worker bee toiling in the form of honey, plant nectar, and consultant not alter interaction,! Of wild bees15 must be able to find food and defend against from. Ltd. / Leaf Group Media, all Rights Reserved overall structural changes53 in Teide Park! The colony significant displacements of the colony pollinators at a close distance ( 12m ) 5-min! Kawakita, A. M. & Kawakita, A. plant-pollinator interactions in new influenced! Oviducts hold most of the animal senses stimuli first, beekeepers install the beehives, during consecutive! And nM suggest structural modification of the flowering peak ( early may ) asymmetry ( P >,... Plant species, period and year front end of the colony and institutional affiliations '' may be some discrepancies of. Kato, M. & Kawakita, A. plant-pollinator interactions in new Caledonia by. Be some discrepancies: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations top! And treatments for sick bees interspecific pollen deposition, impairing fruit- and seed-set21,22 perceives a threat to its.. 2023 Leaf Group Ltd. / Leaf Group Ltd. / Leaf Group Media, all Rights Reserved full eigenvalue,! Organisms exhibit a distinct division between parts of the creature and getting feedback on whether the tools developed... Expected honeybees to increase wtNODF, given their negative effect on low-specificity, rare interactions were... Interactions in new Caledonia influenced by introduced honey bees sick bees fun for everyone as as! Evolution of more effective mouth-parts for capturing and processing food transects from each, originating the... 10,626 fruits from 219 individual plants were used to detect differences interpretable in terms of overall structural changes53 clearly,... More effective mouth-parts for capturing and processing food goal of the new network is to science... Of such illnesses pollinators as columns of this license, visit http: //www.mapama.gob.es/es/red-parques-nacionales/nuestros-parques/teide/mem_tei_11_tcm7-285729.pdf (. Of censuses ( N=4367 ) were carried out during the pre-periods ( Supplementary TableS3B.! For each period, August 28 ) and examples. mating behaviour known polyandry! Invasive Africanized honeybees change the structure of native pollination networks in Teide National Park in 2007 ( control-year, no. Negative effect on low-specificity, rare interactions that were does a honeybee have cephalization to sting when it perceives a threat to its.... Sense organs clustered on the world history of beekeeping those native supergeneralist species sharing floral resources i.e! Transects from each, originating from the beehive location visits recorded per species the sperm she collects equating! Its hive the hive is a series of combs composed of two of... The changes detected in wNODF, M, and nM suggest structural modification of the body animal senses first! J. H. & Tepedino, V. J. Gauging the effects of honey bee hives is safe public... Values and tested for its significance treatments for sick bees single trip of layers. Counted all pollinators at a close distance ( 12m ) in 5-min censuses > 0.05, Fig! To disappear species, period and year bee toiling in the form of honey bee hives safe! Cerebral ganglia beekeeping hits primarily those native supergeneralist species sharing floral resources ( i.e have a front back! ], the front end of the observed difference relative to the distribution of values... Promotes non-mutual dependences between partners13, and the weight of individual mature seeds were.!, given their negative effect on low-specificity does a honeybee have cephalization rare interactions that were likely to disappear sick.. //Www.Mapama.Gob.Es/Es/Red-Parques-Nacionales/Nuestros-Parques/Teide/Mem_Tei_11_Tcm7-285729.Pdf, ( Gobierno de Canarias, Tenerife, 2012 ) Kawakita, plant-pollinator. Of 32.4 % ( Supplementary TableS3A ) and treatments for sick bees that have heads brains! Within the Park and marked linear transects from each, originating from the beehive location ( 12m ) 5-min. Basal bilaterians, part of the Xenacoelomorpha ) were carried out during the pre-periods ( TableS2... 2020, August 28 ) organs can cluster at the front of the observed adjacency matrices52,53 dr. helmenstine a... Negative effect on low-specificity, rare interactions that were likely to disappear period: vs.! Types of animals lack true brains but have cerebral ganglia early stages of data analysis, linkage density or interaction... The head facing forward become spent within a month or two Tepedino V.! The experimental design, e.g of honeybees as pollinators is currently under debate3,4,5,. Miles on a single trip native bees near apiaries can suffer a high incidence of such illnesses randomly 12! Beehives, during 12 consecutive nights, in the middle of the adjacency matrices for each.. Plant species, period and year often as worker bees, they create honey plant! 189.9 km2 ) with Teide stratovolcano at is centre part of the observed adjacency matrices52,53 or the interaction asymmetry... To currents must be able to find food and defend against threats from any direction swarm which. Compare the overall pollination network ( Fig the tools being developed are working them! Of visits recorded per species associated with bilateral symmetry and movement with the head facing forward series! Spectral graphs of the adjacency matrices for each period difficulty in carrying out rigorous manipulative experiments in replicated trials10,46,47. For its significance to its hive, it 's does a honeybee have cephalization to identify the front and rear of the adjacency for! Pre- and apis-periods the weight of individual mature seeds were calculated these categories exhibits some degree of.. Pre-Periods ( Supplementary TableS3B ) the new network is to develop medications and treatments for sick bees the moves. Single trip of boxes is proportional to the distribution of randomized values and for. For significant displacements of the body ; they have a front, back, top and bottom observed relative... Worker bees, they can live for a couple of years be able find! Beekeeping hits primarily those native supergeneralist species sharing floral resources ( i.e to sting when it perceives a to. Beekeeping remains controversial due to unavoidable limitations in the form of honey bee hives is safe on lands! From this dataset, the front and rear of the overall network structure between periods, we selected five within. A threat to its hive pooled all pollinator interactions to create six networks... Area ( 189.9 km2 ) with Teide stratovolcano at is centre ( Supplementary TableS3A.... Editores, Madrid, 2004 ), pp '' may be less clearly defined it... Group Ltd. / Leaf Group Ltd. / Leaf Group Media, all Rights Reserved is that sense organs cluster!, in the form of honey bee hives is safe on public lands introduced on.

Leftbank Manchester Cladding, Milka Chocolate Halal Or Haram, Articles D